March, 1991                                                              PDF Version

Phytophthora Root Rot Resistance
Phytophthora megasperma Drechs. f. sp. medicaginis 

Judy A. Thies and Donald K. Barnes

PLANT CULTURE

Field Methods(3)

No. of Plants ....  40 to 60 per replication
No. of Reps ...... 3 or 4 replications
Other ............... Plant in early May on a level area with relatively heavy soil, but with good internal drainage

Greenhouse Method

Container ......... 20 cm deep watertight tanks with drain holes and a 2.5 cm diameter pipe placed vertically in one corner to allow flooding sand from bottom of tank
Medium ............ Washed, pasteurized sand
Temp/Light ....... 20 to 24°C (sand temperature); 16 hour
daylength
No. of Plants .... 25 per replication
No. of Reps ...... 4 minimum
Other ............... Inoculate with Rhizobium meliloti Dang and fertilize

INOCULUM CULTURE

Greenhouse Method

Source ............. Culture on V-8 juice agar in 9 cm petri dishes
Maintenance ..... Store cultures on V-8 juice agar at 4°C

INOCULATION PROCEDURE

Field Method

Type of Inoc....... Select a field that is naturally infested; or spread infested soil from several geographic areas over the field, incorporate to a depth of about 15 cm and grow a susceptible variety for one year prior to using the area

Greenhouse Method

Age of Plant...... Plant seed into sand
Type of Inoc...... Two week old cultures
Concentration.... Mix inoculum with sand before planting at a rate of one petri dish per 500 cm2 surface area

INCUBATION

Field Method

Plant Counts .... Count plants (alive + dead) when seedlings are in the unifoliolate stage
Culture ............. About 4 weeks after planting, irrigate each day for 3 weeks to keep soil continuously saturated, allow soil to dry for 1week, clip plants, and cultivate soil. Repeat the sequence two more times. Spray for insects as needed
Row Spacing .... Approximately 0.3 m
Age at Rating.... 14 to 15 weeks after planting

Greenhouse Method

Plant Counts .... Same as field method
Culture ............. Water seedlings sparingly until they are well established (4 weeks), plug drain holes and water daily to raise water level surface; maintain flooded conditions for about 4 weeks
Row Spacing .... Approximately 3.5 cm
Age at Rating.... 8 weeks after planting

RATING

Dig all plants retaining 25 cm or more of the taproot. Spray roots to remove excess soil, bundle plants, and soak roots in a tub of water. Complete washing and rate plants indoors under uniform light.

1 Resistant ....... Roots clean no lesions; many small rootlets on taproot
2 Resistant ....... Small root lesions (2mm); small rootlets absent
3 Susceptible .... Large nongirdling root lesion(s) and/or branch root tips rotted off
4 Susceptible .... Extensive lesions with ends of large tap or lateral roots rotted off 10 cm or more below the crown.
5 Susceptible .... Tap and lateral roots almost destroyed; plant alive.
6 Susceptible .... Plants dead (calculated as loss in stand)

CHECK CULTIVARS

  Approximate Expected Reaction (%) Acceptable Range of Resistance (%)
Resistant    
Agate** 43 25-55
Susceptible    
Saranac** 3 0-10

Values for resistant standards include total of l's and 2's.

DISTRIBUTION AND SEVERITY OF PHYTOPHTHORA ROOT ROT

Phytophthora root rot, Phytophthora megasperma Drechs. f. sp. medicaginis (3)

Click on the map above for a larger version. Se e also the KEY.

SOURCES OF INOCULUM AND EXPERTISE

Name ...............Judy A. Thies
Address ............USDA/ARS and
                         Department of Plant Pathology
                         University of Minnesota,
                         495 Borlaug Hall
                         1991 Upper Buford Circle
                         St. Paul, MN 55108
Phone .............. 612-625-8240

Name. ..............Craig R. Grau
Address ............Department of Plant Pathology
                         University of Wisconsin - Madison
                         Madison, WI 53706
Phone................608-262-6289

CORRELATION TO FIELD REACTION

 Field and greenhouse evaluations were correlated (r = 0.99 and 0.95) in two tests. (3). Field tests tend to be more precise, with greenhouse tests useful for screening.

PATHOTYPES

 Isolates of Phytophthora megasperma with different levels of pathogenicity on alfalfa cultivars exist (2). Therefore, it is important to use a mixture of highly palhogenic isolates.

PLANT GROWTH OPTIONS AND RANGE OF CONDITIONS

Monitor root rot development during the season. Symptoms can be increased or reduced by changing the frequency and/ or amount of irrigation. Potato leafhopper control is very important in the Midwest.

HELPFUL INFORMATION

Ratings may be expressed as an average severity index (A.S.I.) which is most precise, or percentage of resistant plants (3) which can be adjusted to a standard check to compare entries between tests. The percentage of plants adjusted to Agate is useful for comparing cultivars tested in different years.

ALTERNATIVE METHODS

 Greenhouse tests using zoospores (1) in a method analogous to that used for Aphanomyces (4) has been successfully used to rank lines although the percent resistant plants is somewhat lower than field test results.

REFERENCES

 1. Irwin, J.A.G., S.A. Miller, and D.P. Maxwell. 1979. Alfalfa seedling resistance to Phytophthora megasperma. Phytopathology 69:1051-1055.

 2. Faris, M. A. 1985. Variability and interaction between alfalfa cultivars and isolates of Phytophthora megasperma. Phytopathology 75:390-394.

 3. Frosheiser, F. I., and D. K. Barnes. 1984. In Standard tests to characterize pest resistance in alfalfa cultivars. USDA Misc. Pub. No. 1434.

 4. Nygard, Sharie, and Craig Grau. 1991. In Standard tests to characterize alfalfa. NAAIC.

Previous Page